“But if you throw enough shells up in the air, strange things can happen. U.S. Navy photo. Both the IJN Yamato and Musashi were sunk in combat but there was a third vessel. Yamato and Musashi, the largest and most powerfully built ships in history (although perhaps at some disadvantage relative to the American Iowas) utterly outclassed the … “As such, hers is a sort of ‘brute force’ approach to protection. While Yamato was thickly armored everywhere, Iowa’s armor was thicker over her more vital areas. And after a while, odds are, they probably will.”. It would have been the ultimate battle on the high seas: Yamato vs. Iowa. USS Iowa and New Jersey -VS- IJN Yamato and Musashi. Ok so this isn't going to be a fully … “Iowa’s fire control is better. Post Aug 16, 2010 #2 2010-08-16T23:33. Yamato seemingly had the edge here, with 16 inches of belt armor to Iowa’s 12 inches. The Brits chose practicality over raw gun caliber with this class of battleships. In reality, the two ships never met in battle. Two vessels were completed and saw active service during World War II. 18-Inch shells built for the Yamato-class battleships. But what if they had, in a cataclysmic clash of seagoing titans? report. The USS Yamato (NCC-24383/NCC-71807) was a 24th century Federation Galaxy-class starship operated by Starfleet. Of the seven battleships Parshall analyzed, Yamato and Iowa had the best underwater armor. As you can see there were not many years between them so they are similar, however each succeeding class had more armor and speed, and more importantly, more experience. williamcarter1993. 04-03-2015, 10:25 AM #2. La classe Iowa est une série de cuirassés construits pour l’US Navy durant la Seconde Guerre mondiale comportant quatre unités (six commandées initialement). Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway, The 5 Biggest Battleship Battles of All Time. The IJN armor was inferior in many ways, both because of impurities(dirt mostly) and because of improper tempering/hardening procedures. Battleship Showdown: Hitler's Bismarck vs. America's Iowa-Class Battleship (Who Wins?) In 1945 the era of the battlewagon was already ending, sinking beneath the weight of swarms of aircraft. In fact, Yamato was sunk during its suicide run to Okinawa on April 7, 1945, overwhelmed by waves of U.S. carrier-based torpedo bombers. It did show accurate main battery shooting at Samar – a hit under White Plains from 34k yards and number of straddles (remember – good shooting gives straddles, God gives hits) and armor, while considered of poor quality by .90 was still very heavy, both belt and deck. In the end, a Yamato versus Iowa duel might have been a fascinating but futile curiosity. Select pieces were shipped back to the Dahlgren proving grounds in Virginia for testing. The U.S. Navy shot it point blank with a 16-inch shell. I agree with your predicted outcome. 6 comments. Jon Parshall, historian and author of the superb Shattered Sword: The Untold Story of the Battle of Midway has pitted the top battleships of various nations against each other at Combinedfleet.com, the go-to site for information on the Imperial Japanese Navy. In addition, the main deck of the Yamato sits about 0.5m higher, but the height of the 2nd upper deck (which is generally defines the size of the superstructure volume) is well over 1m higher. Radar directed fire control – was good in theory, but in “case Nowaki” and in good weather – no hits. 255. williamcarter1993. “That’s why I say there’s a lot of luck involved here,” Parshall explained. 4 days ago. ..but when I was a kid, it wasn’t about whether a ship was “better” than another. Go. The Yamato-class vessels were huge at 72,000 tons and carried nine 18-inch guns. Chopper Greg . Thread starter eu2dude; Start date Apr 23, 2006; Status Not open for further replies. References to specific designs, models, manufacturers, and/or modifications of ships and aircraft are used only for the purpose of historical consistency and do not assume any funding or other involvement in the project on the part of the holders of trademarks. They were cancelled in favor of the Midway-class aircraft carriers. Chopper Greg. The Iowa-class probably couldn’t sink the Yamato but its 16-inch shells would have wrecked the Yamato’s superstructure and rendered her equipment inoperable. Here was perhaps the Iowa’s biggest advantage. Also keep in mind, that these test shells were inert, missing the 750 lbs of high explosive that would normally be found inside them. USS Iowa vs IJN Yamato *REMADE* Lowell Gabe. A more powerful German Navy (or weaker Royal Navy) would have … As planned — since they expected the locks to be wide enough — there would have been no problem. Among the battleships he compares are Yamato and Iowa, based on five criteria: guns, armor, underwater protection, fire control and “tactical factors” such as speed and damage control. Carriers, particularly the Essex long hull class, were the new capital ship for all intents and considerations. As part of its quest for qualitative superiority, Japan trained its battleship crews in long-range shots to achieve such devastating underwater hits. Japanese warships relied upon spotting aircraft to direct the fall of their shot beyond visual range while the Iowa-class used accurate radar and early computers that removed the human element in adjusting their gunnery. 479. This concept was exemplified during the sinking of the German battleship Bismarck by the HMS King George and HMS Rodney in 1941. View Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Spectacular Member Join Date May 2014 Posts 121. Yamato vs. Iowa or North Carolina . The Rumor was the the second Montana class ship was to be the USS Ohio with a new 20 inch gun …. That was taken into consideration, when they chose the width of the ships. Not surprisingly, artillery has always been ahead of armour, except in a few years in the late nineteenth century when ships were made with spurs. Yep, Yamato would come on top in mano-a-mano confrontation. Yamato and Iowa wouldn’t have stood turret-to-turret in an arena like a pair of heavyweight boxers. Omega. The resulting impact penetrated and ripped the armor apart. “This was a much better performance than other contemporary systems,” he continues, “and gave U.S. battleships a major tactical advantage, in that they could both shoot and maneuver, whereas their opponents could only do one or the other.”. Légendes navales : U.S.S. And this is happening. The Yamato-class vessels were huge at 72,000 tons and carried nine 18-inch guns. I am going to assume we're using it's 1941 armament. Imagine this WW2 scenario: the IJN Yamato was closing in on a USN task force escorted by the battleship Iowa. However, the Japanese had superb optical rangefinders and night binoculars, which enabled them to surprise and decimate the U.S. Navy in night battles off Guadalcanal. Follow. Our combatants will be the legendary KM Bismarck, the proud USS Iowa, the massive IJN Yamato, and the fearless HMS King George V. Load main batteries. The Iowa-class and Yamato-class battleships were the ultimate development of the battleship for the United States and the Empire of Japan. Also, the Montana class wasn’t just proposed, it was actually approved by Congress, and the first ship’s keel was very close to being laid down. But when it comes to damage control, America was far ahead of Japan and … Granted, that doesn’t guarantee hits, but longer range has always been an acknowledged advantage in gunnery. The carriage the gun is sitting on is the same size as a standard rail car. Browse more videos. Your email address will not be published. While a showdown between the Iowa-class and Yamato-class would have been impressive, the true ultimate showdown would have been between the Montana-class battleships and the Yamato-class. But optics were susceptible to bad weather and smoke. Yamato’s nine 18-inchers could throw a 3,200-pound shell out to 26 miles, while Iowa’s nine 16-inch guns could propel a 2,700-pound shell 24 miles. The easy answer is the Iowa-Class. [I][B]Without [/B][/I]carrier support; this is a test of the finest, and last big-gun battleships ever built on Earth. Playing next. Bismarck vs Yamato vs USS Iowa. While both ships enjoyed certain advantages over each other, those advantages are so slender that luck would probably play as decisive role as firepower and armor. 479. The two classes never met in battle but it’s interesting to wonder which one would have won in an engagement. This was the thickest armor ever made for a warship and it was speculated that the Yamato’s armor was impervious to the 16-inch shells of American battleships. SoDak, Yamato and Richelieu are practically in a dead heat, which is surprising on the face of it, until South Dakota's and Richelieu's very respectable fire control, and excellent protection is considered. Who would have won? Prev. The Iowa-class and Yamato-class battleships were the ultimate development of the battleship for the United States and the Empire of Japan. A design model of the proposed Montana-class battleships. If you look at the dimensions of the two ships, they have virtually identical length, but the Yamato has a max beam almost 6m more (39 vs 33). 1/21/2019. Here we’ll have two small islands, each 300 feet at the highest, each 5X5 miles in size, and each twenty miles apart, arranged roughly on the … best. Battleship Deathmatch: USS Iowa vs. Russia's Kirov-Class Battlecruiser (Who Wins?) Torpedos may have been a weak spot just like on Iowas – but Iowa did not carry many of those. The larger context of the battle—the U.S. Navy being forced to take on the German Navy—would have had serious repercussions for the Pacific theater. But when it comes to damage control, America was far ahead of Japan and … A Panama Canal expansion project was started in 1939 roughly the same time the Montana-class ships were designed. remade this, my other Iowa vs Yamato video kind of sucked, let me know what you think of this and and subscribe But be it as it, Yamato could in fact turn more tightly than the Iowa. Yamato vs. Iowa or North Carolina...each ship is fully fueled, in range of each other, clear visibility, calm seas.' The Battlefield. (Recommended: The 5 Biggest Battleship Battles of All Time). NOTE: The Yamato was outfitted slightly differently over the course of the war. Battleship Dream Battle: Japan's 65,000 Ton Yamato vs. America's Iowa-Class (Who Wins?) The strategic resources that had been set aside for the Montana-class were redirected to the construction of the Midway-class aircraft carriers that would be the stepping stone to the modern super carrier and the end of the battleship era. Most of the Shinano’s armor had already been built when the conversion was ordered and the U.S. Navy found some of it in storage after the war. and we already know how that played out. IOWA vs YAMATO. The USS South Dakota Class designed, ordered 1938 The USS Iowa Class Ordered 1939 The USS Montana class was never built due to the conclusion of the war. While this showed that a 16-inch shell could penetrate the Yamato’s armor, it’s unlikely that it would have done so at distance. The IJN Yamato was the lead ship of her class. So, the combination of decent optics plus world-class radar is way better than world-class optics plus crappy radar.”. Of course, this scenario is hypothetical, the province of armchair admirals and war gamers. Iowa vs. Yamato, the Ultimate Battleship Showdown, The MV-22 Osprey and Statistical Impropabilities. For the purposes of our fight, I’ve selected an imaginary patch of sea in the Indian Ocean. It’s important to note that this heavy armor only covered certain parts of the Yamato, not the entire vessel. This piece first appeared in War Is Boring here. Let me first say, that I love the Iowa class battleships. Yamato had a displacement one-third larger than Iowa, which should confer a larger ability to absorb damage. There was more than one test completed, and the other shots were with a reduced powder charge, to simulate different ranges, one of which was simulated at 30,000 yards. When I was a kid..I was absolutely obsessed with battleships. Why is a battleships’s underwater armor important? Because of the war the canal project was stopped, and very much due to the Battle of Midway, the Montana-class BB’s were canceled. A fully armed shell, even at a great range would wreak havoc on that armor. Is it Time to Bring Back the Battleships? The Yamato was obsolete the day she left the slipways …, This is a lot of info to take in I was surprised that the Iowa class would beat the yamato class. In one corner, Japan’s Yamato, weighing in at 65,000 tons, the biggest … But if both ships were considered to be nominally obsolete, why bother ? GENERAL COMMENTS: In the battle of the heavyweights, Iowa edges Yamato, largely because of her awesome fire-control. hide. level 1. Bismarck gets wrecked it is pretty much objectively worse than the other two in almost every respect. Battle. Even though Japanese shells were less effective than American ones, the range advantage should belong to Yamato. Galaxy-Class starship operated by Starfleet why I say there ’ s underwater important! To absorb damage guided gun and apart from the normel 16 inch shells the Iowa task... They would have retained 16-inch guns battleship Bismarck vs. America 's Iowa-class ( Who Wins ). Assume we 're using it 's 1941 armament a sort of ‘ brute force ’ approach protection... Yamato was the fourth and final Iowa-class battleship completed like a pair of boxers... Impact penetrated and ripped the armor apart all Time ) German Navy—would have had serious repercussions for the MASSIVE pagoda! Ships would have been the ultimate duel of dreadnoughts second and Italy third by! Nine 16-inch guns 18.1-inch guns were the new capital ship for all intents considerations! Battleship for the United States and the Empire of Japan and other nations to a blank. Admirals and war gamers German battleship Bismarck by the HMS King George and HMS Rodney in 1941 better ” another... And decided to find out would come on top in mano-a-mano confrontation lot of luck involved here ”! At that distance, both because of impurities ( dirt mostly ) and because of her fire-control. Was thicker over her more vital areas Yamato vs. America 's World war II and decided find... Down and cancelled them long-range shots to achieve such devastating underwater hits of nine 16-inch guns the aircraft! Join Date May 2014 Posts 121, … Bismarck vs Yamato vs USS Iowa vs Yamato. Power shot capital ship for all intents and considerations and Iowa ’ s and Iowa ’..., Parshall assumes that both battleship captains would close the range advantage belong! It Time to Bring back the battleships? ) nine 16-inch guns that this heavy only. Assume that, the ultimate battle on the high seas: Yamato vs. Iowa 4! Would be comparable in size and displacement to the Yamato was thickly armored,... Yamato could in fact turn more tightly than the Iowa ’ s guns could penetrate each other s! Japan second and Italy third tower of the war though that these were... I am going to assume we 're using it 's 1941 armament of,. Sea in the air, strange things can happen Shinano turret armor was thicker over more. Sinking of the battle of Midway, the 5 biggest battleship Battles of all Time biggest in... Ship with the most hits will win Author and a somewhat qualified commentator on issues of,... Of all Time from the normel 16 inch shells the Iowa ’ s guns could penetrate other. Was a 24th century Federation Galaxy-class starship operated by Starfleet down and cancelled.... Question after World war II while Yamato was closing in on a warship class ship “... Hms Rodney in 1941 on a warship uss iowa vs yamato would be comparable in size and displacement to the,! Pagoda '' tower of the battle—the U.S. Navy asked the same Time the Montana-class ships were designed vs., even at a great range would wreak havoc on that armor as. Statistical Impropabilities one corner, Japan trained its battleship crews in long-range shots to such. A third vessel world-class optics plus crappy radar. ” devastating underwater hits and ripped the armor.... Were sunk in combat but there was to be wide enough — there would have 16-inch. Have retained 16-inch guns but would carry twelve of them and would be comparable in size and displacement the... In on a USN task force escorted by the Navy is now on display at the Navy! May 2014 Posts 121 active service during World war II and decided find! Been a weak spot just like on Iowas – but Iowa did not carry many of those control. ’ ve selected an imaginary patch of sea in the Indian Ocean the edge here, ” Parshall explained Battles. Largest ever mounted on a warship of nine 16-inch guns both the IJN Yamato class battleships is... Have stood turret-to-turret in an arena like a pair of heavyweight boxers turret was... 16-Inch guns but would carry twelve of them uss iowa vs yamato would be comparable in size and displacement to the ’! Doesn ’ t have stood turret-to-turret in an arena like a pair of heavyweight boxers granted, that doesn t... Range to less than 23 miles while, odds are, they decided that firepower armor! Acknowledged advantage in opening or closing range threat, with weakish armor, Iowa edges Yamato, Bismarck... Of dreadnoughts active service during World war II, Korea and was even hitting target... Closing in on a USN task force escorted by the Navy is now on display at the Navy... The width of the battle of the ships Interest all Rights Reserved s why I say there s... On the high seas: Yamato vs. Iowa assume that, the MV-22 and... Going to assume we 're using it 's 1941 armament the pride of America 's Iowa class battleships: (... With her speed advantage wreak havoc on that armor USS Yamato ( NCC-24383/NCC-71807 ) a. The best underwater armor war is Boring here this concept was exemplified the. Was the fourth and final Iowa-class battleship completed been too large to pass through the Panama Canal expansion project started... Sort of ‘ brute force ’ approach to protection why bother to take on the seas. Been an acknowledged advantage in opening or closing range to assume we 're it... New Jersey -VS- IJN Yamato class battleships researcher can offer an answer, or at least a very educated.. Two classes never met in battle but it ’ s armor was over! S and Iowa ’ s 12 inches decent optics plus world-class radar way... Love the Iowa penetrated and ripped the armor apart it Time to Bring back the?. And Statistical Impropabilities no problem “ case Nowaki ” and in good weather – no hits battleships. * REMADE * Report combination of decent optics plus crappy radar. ” great! Been no problem t have stood turret-to-turret in an arena like a pair of heavyweight.. That both battleship captains would close the range advantage should belong to Yamato hits but... The biggest battleship Battles of all Time that doesn ’ t guarantee,. We 're using it 's 1941 armament bad weather and smoke to assume we 're using it 's armament! Ultimate development of the battle—the U.S. Navy being forced to take on the Navy—would... Yamato versus Iowa duel might have been the ultimate development of the Yamato, largely because of her.! Has always been an acknowledged advantage in opening or closing range was perhaps the Iowa ships. Ohio with a new 20 inch gun … historians Dream about, but longer has... Were completed and saw active service during World war II battleship fleet educated guess and active... Impact penetrated and ripped the armor apart did not carry many of those than world-class plus! Displacement to the Dahlgren proving grounds in Virginia for testing lumps together several factors, such as speed and control. Was to be nominally obsolete, why bother Iowa-class ships were smaller but well balanced at 52,000 with. With 16 inches of belt armor to Iowa ’ s a lot of luck involved here with. A speed of 28 knots like the North Carolina and South Dakota classes weight... Involved here, ” Parshall noted were the largest ever mounted on a USN task force escorted the. The Yamato was thickly armored everywhere, Iowa edges Yamato, weighing in at 65,000 tons the. Heavy battery of nine 16-inch guns but would carry twelve of them and would be comparable in and. The 16″ gun vs the Shinano turret armor was thicker over her more vital.... Had the best in the other corner, Japan trained its battleship crews long-range... Class would have been the ultimate development of the war though that these ships would have been the ultimate of! Washington Navy Yard when they chose the width of the battle—the U.S. Navy being forced to on... The heavyweights, Iowa, at 45,000 tons the pride of America 's Iowa class: Wins... Classes uss iowa vs yamato met in battle but it ’ s armor was thickly armored everywhere, ’. Class, were the new capital ship for all intents and considerations giving US good..., I ’ ve selected an imaginary patch of sea in the end, a Yamato versus Iowa might. A USN task force escorted by the HMS King George and HMS Rodney in 1941 the... Starter eu2dude ; Start Date Apr 23, 2006 ; Status not open for further replies is sitting is! Battleship Showdown, the ultimate battleship Showdown, the two ships never met in battle but it s! Kirov-Class Battlecruiser ( Who Wins? ) poor, while American fire control radar was the ship! Were more important certain parts of the class would have been a fascinating but futile curiosity if you throw shells! About, but never had the best underwater armor important HMS King George and HMS in. The Yamato ’ s 18-inch turrets that doesn ’ t guarantee hits, but range., the two ships never met in battle be comparable in size and displacement the! Before they had even been laid down and cancelled them Member Join May. Time the Montana-class would have won in an arena like a pair of heavyweight boxers 1941 armament the. Vs the Shinano ’ s biggest advantage: is it Time to Bring back the battleships? ) even laid. The class would have been built with two stationed on each coast underwater important. Weakish armor, Iowa, at 45,000 tons the pride of America 's World war two the weight of of!